Málaga Valuations Logo

Málaga Valuations

Discover the REAL value of your property

ES EN
678 716 645
contacto@valoracionesmalaga.com

Contradictory expert appraisal in Andalucía: how to challenge an inflated Modelo 700 tax bill

If the Junta de Andalucía has revised the declared value of your property upwards and issued a higher ITP or inheritance tax demand, Spanish law gives you the right to appoint your own expert valuer and dispute the figure. This guide explains the procedure step by step — in plain English.

📞 Call: +34 678 716 645
✅Free, no obligation
📊Local Málaga market data
⚡Report in 24-48 h
🔒100% confidential

Leer esta página en español →

Important before you read on

The contradictory expert appraisal applies when the tax authority has carried out a value inspection (comprobación de valores) on your property. It does not apply to disputes about the Valor de Referencia del Catastro (the cadastral reference value introduced in 2022): that requires a separate procedure explained on our cadastral reference value page.

When you buy, inherit or receive a property in Málaga or elsewhere in Andalucía, you self-assess the transfer tax (ITP) or inheritance and gift tax (Impuesto sobre Sucesiones y Donaciones) on the value you declare. The Agencia Tributaria de Andalucía may then inspect that value and issue a revised — usually higher — assessment. Under Article 135 of Spain's General Tax Law you can oppose this by commissioning your own expert report. If the gap between your expert's figure and theirs does not exceed either €120,000 or 10%, your figure prevails.

When the contradictory expert appraisal applies — and when it does not

It does apply when

  • The Agencia Tributaria de Andalucía has inspected the value of your property and notified you of an assessment higher than what you declared.
  • That higher figure comes from the authority's own valuation methods — for example, a report by their own valuers.
  • The tax in question is ITP on a purchase, or the inheritance and gift tax (Sucesiones y Donaciones).

It does NOT apply when

  • You declared below the Valor de Referencia del Catastro and that figure is being applied as the minimum tax base.
  • You want to challenge the Valor de Referencia itself: the correct route is to request an amendment of your self-assessment (rectificación de autoliquidación) or appeal the demand, and the authority consults the Catastro.
  • Your disagreement is not about the value but about a different element, such as an exemption or relief.

The process, step by step

  1. Read the notification carefully. Identify the value you declared, the revised value, the method the authority used, and the resulting tax demand. If the notification does not explain how the new figure was reached, tell your adviser: inadequate reasoning can itself be challenged.
  2. Note the deadline immediately. The request must be filed within the period allowed for the first appeal or challenge against the assessment, which starts running from the notification date. This window is short; do not wait until your expert's report is ready to calculate it — confirm the deadline with a professional that same day.
  3. Commission a preliminary valuation to decide whether to proceed. Before paying for a full expert report, it is worth knowing whether the authority's figure is genuinely above market. A free market pre-valuation using comparable sales in your area gives you that first answer. The value that matters is the one at the date of the taxable event (purchase, death or gift), not today's value.
  4. File the application. Address it to the Agencia Tributaria de Andalucía, by their online portal or at a registry office, referencing the specific assessment. Under the General Tax Law, filing suspends enforcement of the demand and pauses the appeal period while the procedure runs. Deciding whether to appeal and to request the expert appraisal simultaneously — or in sequence — is a strategic choice your tax adviser must make.
  5. Appoint your expert when invited to do so. The authority will send you their own expert's report and give you a period to name yours. The expert must hold a qualification appropriate to the type of property (for residential, normally an architect or technical architect). Make sure their report is supported by verifiable comparable evidence; a generic valuation carries little weight.
  6. Compare the two valuations. If the difference between your expert's figure and the authority's figure does not exceed €120,000 AND does not exceed 10%, your figure prevails as the tax base. Both conditions must be met simultaneously.
  7. If the gap is larger, a third expert is appointed. This is done in accordance with the law, drawing on professional lists supplied by the relevant colleges. Their valuation then sets the tax base within the legal limits. Ask your adviser about any deposits or costs that may arise before starting the procedure.
  8. Check the revised assessment. Once the value is settled, a new tax demand is issued. Verify that the value applied is the one that emerged from the procedure and that the tax has been correctly recalculated.
€120,000 and 10%the two thresholds: if the gap between your expert's figure and the authority's figure stays within both limits, your figure prevails without a third expertSource: Article 135 of Spain's General Tax Law (Ley General Tributaria)

A worked example: when your expert wins and when a third expert is needed

Hypothetical example

Heirs declare a country house in the Valle del Guadalhorce for €180,000. Assume no Valor de Referencia applies and the Agencia Tributaria de Andalucía later inspects and fixes the value at €240,000. The heirs request a contradictory expert appraisal. Two possible outcomes:

Two variants of the same case (hypothetical figures)
VariantHeirs' expert valuationGap versus authority's figureGap as % of heirs' figureOutcome
A€225,000€15,0006.7%Heirs' valuation prevails
B€200,000€40,00020%10% threshold exceeded: third expert required

In variant B, a gap of just €40,000 triggers the third-expert stage — it is below €120,000 but exceeds 10%. On expensive properties the reverse can happen: on a €1.5m villa, a 9% gap already exceeds €120,000. If your property is a country estate, see also what the valuer looks at when assessing a rural property in Málaga.

Does it make financial sense to challenge the assessment?

The procedure is not free: you pay your expert's fees and, if a third expert is needed, additional costs may arise. The useful question is how much tax is actually at stake:

  • On ITP for a purchase, each additional euro of assessed value is taxed at the applicable rate (the standard rate for second-hand residential is 7%). In the example above, €60,000 of excess value would add €4,200 to the bill.
  • On inheritance tax between parents, children and spouses in Andalucía, the 99% relief dramatically reduces the immediate impact. Even so, the declared value matters if the property is later sold, as it affects the capital gain.
  • For other groups of heirs — siblings, nephews, nieces — with no such relief, the difference in assessed value can translate into a significant additional charge.

Practical tips

Keep all documentation from the purchase or inheritance: title deeds, photographs showing the property's condition at the relevant date, and any repair estimates help your expert justify a lower value. Do not let the deadline slip while you wait for the expert's report. For properties in the Málaga area with wide price variation — older flats without lifts in the city centre, rural scattered-plot houses, country estates with ageing structures — make sure comparables are drawn from genuinely similar properties nearby.

Frequently asked questions about contradictory expert appraisals in Andalucía

An appeal challenges whether the tax authority acted correctly in law — for example, whether the valuation method was appropriate. The contradictory expert appraisal disputes the figure itself, pitting your expert's valuation against theirs. They are separate tools that can sometimes be combined; your tax adviser should decide which to use first once they have seen the notification.

It is a useful pointer, because it was produced by a regulated valuation firm close to the purchase date. Hand it to your expert valuer. However, it does not replace their own report: the procedure requires a valuation signed by the expert you appoint, referenced to the date of the taxable event. If the bank figure matched what you declared, that strengthens your case.

There is no guaranteed timeframe: it depends on the tax authority's workload, the time needed to appoint experts, and whether a third expert is required. Importantly, enforcement of the tax demand is suspended while the procedure is running. Respond promptly to each request and keep proof of everything you submit.

File with the Agencia Tributaria de Andalucía, preferably through their online portal using a digital certificate or Cl@ve, or at any official registry, citing the specific tax assessment you are disputing. If you submit on paper, keep a date-stamped copy as proof you met the deadline. The appeal instructions on your original notice indicate the correct office.

Has the Junta de Andalucía revised your property value upwards?

Send us the notification and your property details. A free market pre-valuation will tell you whether the authority's figure is out of line with the market — before you decide whether to commission a full contradictory appraisal.

4 + 8 = ?

* Required fields. Free pre-valuation with no obligation; please also check your spam folder.

Data protection: Controller: Valoraciones Málaga. Purpose: preparing your valuation and contacting you about it. Legal basis: your consent. Your request is received at info@malagaviviendas.com; we do not sell your data or disclose it to anyone else unless legally required. You can exercise your rights of access, rectification and erasure by writing to contacto@valoracionesmalaga.com.

📞

Call us directly

+34 678 716 645

Monday to Friday 8:00–20:00 · Saturday 9:00–14:00 (Spanish time)

📞Call now
⚡

Fast response

• We contact you within 2 hours
• Report within 24–48 hours
• 100% free, no obligation

📧

Valoraciones Málaga

Calle Limonar, 12
29130 Alhaurín de la Torre, Málaga, Spain
contacto@valoracionesmalaga.com